The government of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has sent Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF), the country's highest court, a survey of 60,677 records tied to the promotion of illegal online betting. The Ministry of Justice and Public Security collected them between September 25 and November 9. The material went to Justice Luiz Fux and is part of the government's defense in the case, which aims to keep the ban on fixed-odds betting, known in Brazil as "bets."
What the 60,677 records actually measure
The survey adds up websites, social media pages, influencer profiles and groups on messaging apps. In other words, it is a picture of advertising, not of betting itself.
Of the 60,677 records, 51,611 were pages promoting illegal betting sites, about 85% of everything observed in the period. The reach calculation came to 204.2 million users. But the ministry itself acknowledges that this total does not mean different people, because the same user can appear on more than one platform. In practice, 204 million is a sum of overlapping audiences. Nobody knows how many people were actually reached.
348 Instagram profiles and 150 million followers
The strongest point in the survey is the pressure on platforms. The ministry asked for the removal of 348 Instagram profiles identified as tools for promoting these activities. Together, the accounts had more than 150 million followers, a figure that, as with the reach number, does not necessarily represent unique users.
The document leaves a large gap. It does not say how many removal requests the platforms complied with, or how many pages and accounts remain active. It also does not say how many bets were placed. It shows reach and the number of records, but not results.
Why it matters: what is at stake at the Supreme Court
The material is part of the documentation sent by the Attorney General's Office (AGU), the federal government's legal arm, to support keeping the ban on fixed-odds betting. The government wants the court to weigh the size of the digital problem as an argument for keeping the rule.
The central question is simple: is the ban reducing illegal supply, or just changing where it appears? The 60,000 records suggest the advertising is still circulating on a large scale, and the government itself admits that containing this content on social networks is a challenge.
Banning is not enforcing: a conservative reading for investors and observers
This is VDD's editorial view. People who defend economic freedom and a smaller state have long been wary of broad prohibitions that do not come with clear results. If the government wants to convince the STF, it needs to show efficiency: how many pages were taken down, how many profiles were actually removed, and how much the country stopped losing to the black market. Without that data, the reach figure becomes a statistic built for effect, not proof of a working public policy.
For foreign readers following Brazil's betting market and its courts, the case is one to watch. The debate goes well beyond an impressive number in a legal filing. It concerns the line between protecting consumers and controlling an entire market, and it is up to the Supreme Court to decide how much weight to give a defense that still does not show what has really worked.




