Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF), the country's highest court, faces one of the most delicate moments of its recent history. On Wednesday (Nov. 18), the court's president, Edson Fachin, receives from the director-general of the Federal Police (PF), Andrei Rodrigues, reports that reference justices of the court and their relatives in the case of Banco Master and its former banker, Daniel Vorcaro. The meeting is scheduled for after the day's plenary session.
What Fachin decides will say a lot about how the STF handles suspicions that land at its own door.
Fachin's choice: prosecutors or an internal review
The documents gather mentions, citations and other records found by the PF during the investigation. The key point: the material does not necessarily reach any conclusion about a crime or irregularity. They are references, and Fachin must decide how to classify them.
Two paths are on the table. The first is to send everything to the Prosecutor General's Office (PGR). There, Prosecutor General Paulo Gonet would assess whether there is evidence that justifies a criminal inquiry, before any deliberation by the full court.
The second is an internal screening of an administrative and disciplinary nature. Under that model, the STF president could request a preliminary assessment of how consistent the information is, or even ask the PF for additional work. In other words, the Supreme Court would first examine what concerns the Supreme Court itself.
Six justices named and pressure on the court
What raises the temperature is the scope. At least six STF justices are cited, at different levels, in the findings. There are also names linked to the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) and the Superior Labor Court (TST).
The delivery coincides with the first anniversary of the initial phase of Operation Compliance Zero, launched to investigate suspected fraud tied to Banco Master and its connections. Fachin will also have to define in which situations cited justices may take part in trials related to the matter.
The week before, Rodrigues phoned Fachin to discuss the model used to prepare the reports. The call came after the departure of investigators who took part in producing documents on the references to justices and to Vorcaro, which added to the tension around the case.
What is already public, and what those named say
The controversy has a known sequence. In April 2025, it was revealed that the law firm of the wife of Justice Alexandre de Moraes had been hired by Banco Master. In December, reports emerged that the contract was worth about R$ 130 million (Brazilian reais).
Later, data attributed to the PF pointed to at least 52 messages from Vorcaro to Moraes, including on the day the former banker was arrested. Moraes denies having had those exchanges and says he committed no irregularities.
Justice André Mendonça was also cited, after the release of a photo with a Vorcaro lawyer, of a meeting with the banker, and of a request for an investigation into a possible relationship between Banco Master and the Iter Institute, which is linked to the justice. Elsewhere there are references to Justice Gilmar Mendes, involving the hiring of Chiquinho Feitosa, the justice's former brother-in-law, as well as a meeting and attempts at approaching him. All the justices and relatives mentioned deny any wrongdoing or improper involvement in dealings with Vorcaro.
Who investigates the court? Why it matters beyond Brazil
The standoff is institutional before it is legal. If the material stays in internal screening, the court risks being seen as a judge in its own cause, which weighs on the trust of those who expect impartiality from the judiciary. If it goes to the PGR, the analysis moves to an outside body, with the political cost that carries.
Mentions are not guilt, and everyone involved denies irregularities. But in VDD's editorial view, taxpayers who fund the public machinery have a right to transparency when the names of justices of the highest court appear in a case involving suspected financial fraud. From a conservative standpoint, a strong state is one that is accountable, and that applies first of all to those with the power to judge.
For foreign observers, the episode is a test of whether Brazil's top court will accept scrutiny of itself, a question that bears on perceptions of judicial independence and institutional credibility.
The next step is the announcement of where the reports will go. Fachin may send the material to the PGR, open the internal screening or ask the PF for more information. Whichever he chooses, it will be read as a signal of how far the Supreme Court is willing to be examined.




