Brasília --:--:--
Politics

Lula's fiscal package reaches Brazil's lower house under fire

The 'Moretti Plan' goes to the Chamber of Deputies Monday with no guaranteed vote: markets say it is too small, the PT left says it goes too far, the right alleges a 'calote'.

Brazil's Chamber of Deputies in Brasília, where Lula's fiscal adjustment package awaits a vote
Photo: Lula. Foto: Lula Oficial / CC BY-SA 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

The fiscal adjustment package of Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (Workers' Party, PT) arrives at the Chamber of Deputies, the lower house of Congress in Brasília, squeezed from every side. The Senate approved the text on Wednesday (Nov. 18). It is on the agenda for Monday's session (Nov. 23) at 6 p.m. Brasília time, but it still needs an urgency request to go straight to the floor. Lawmakers do not guarantee that the vote on the substance will happen that same day.

The bill was presented as Lula's gesture to 'put the accounts in order' after the elections. It even earned a nickname, the 'Moretti Plan', after Planning and Budget Minister Bruno Moretti. The result, however, has pleased neither side.

Markets say it is too little, the PT's base says it is too much

According to the Executive, the measures should improve Brazil's 2027 primary result (the budget balance before interest payments) by R$ 45.1 billion to R$ 50.1 billion (Brazilian reais). Financial markets expected far more: at least double the R$ 50 billion budgeted by the Senate rapporteur, Eduardo Braga (MDB-AM). For investors, the size of the adjustment is insufficient.

On the opposite flank, the PT's more ideological wing is complaining. The party's deputy leader in the Chamber, Lindbergh Farias (PT-RJ), questioned the change in the calculation base for the federal health spending floor. The change excludes extraordinary oil and gas revenue from net current revenue (RCL) and slows the growth of the floor. Part of the government's base also criticized what it saw as a nod to business. Lula went to an event at the Planalto presidential palace to defend the plan and rebut accusations of 'cutting rights'. Moretti met with PT leaders to seek consensus.

'Pedalada' and 'calote': the opposition's offensive

In the Senate, opposition leader Rogério Marinho (Liberal Party, PL-RN) compared the measure to a 'pedalada fiscal', Brazilian shorthand for budget maneuvers that make the accounts look better. According to him, after approval, the people would grasp the 'calote' (a default or stiffing of creditors) carried out by the government.

The target is the change to the rules of the Kandir Law, which deals with ICMS, the state-level tax on goods and services, and the exemption for exports. The bill planned to cut transfers to states and municipalities from R$ 4 billion to R$ 1 billion per year, plus R$ 12 billion paid in installments through 2037. After a deal with the opposition, the government will raise the transfers from R$ 1 billion to R$ 2 billion, with payoff by 2030.

Opposition attempts to toughen the text were blocked in the Senate. A separate vote on the R$ 3 billion annual cap on offsets between pension regimes failed 45 to 32. A ban on the government restricting credits used to pay federal taxes failed 49 to 31. An extra spending-control measure failed 47 to 30.

What the bill changes in practice

The Chamber rapporteur, Mauro Benevides Filho (União-CE), presented his opinion on Thursday (Nov. 19) with no changes to the substance, so that the bill does not go back to the Senate. Chamber Speaker Hugo Motta (Republicanos-PB) signaled he should put it to a vote. Because it is a complementary law, 257 votes are needed. Key points:

  • The cap on real growth of primary spending may fall from 2.5% to 2% from 2027, in years when the government adopts containment measures.
  • The Executive may expand spending freezes to aim for the center of the primary-result target, not just the lower limit of the tolerance band.
  • The government may restrict offsets between taxes, which may bring cash into the Treasury sooner.
  • Federal tax benefits and incentives take an additional cut of 10 percentage points, reaching 20%, with presumed credits limited to 80% of the original value.
  • The authorization to free up to 40% of the financial surplus of earmarked funds was dropped. That mechanism was tied to a R$ 100 billion improvement in the margin of the 'golden rule' (which limits borrowing to fund current spending).
  • Debt service, science and technology funds financed by a specific fund, and expenses exempted by the budget guidelines law (LDO) are protected from cuts.
  • Transfers to the Federal District Constitutional Fund remain adjusted by RCL, including in 2027.

Why Lula's package matters for investors and Brazil's budget

Brazil's fiscal path is one of the main things investors watch, and the government's own stated aim is to give the budget predictability and open the way for lower interest rates. A package that markets call timid, that the governing party's own base criticizes, and that is already followed by talk of a new package at the Planalto, leaves that goal uncertain.

VDD's editorial view is that much of the package targets revenue: it reduces tax benefits, limits credits and restricts offsets. That weighs on those who produce and invest, while the spending cut appears as an authorization to the government, not an obligation. The opposition tried to turn that authorization into an obligation and lost.

Monday is the next chapter. If the urgency request passes and the quorum of 257 appears, the text goes to presidential sanction. If not, Lula's fiscal impasse gets another week of wear.

Translated and adapted from the original report by Visão da Direita (Portuguese). Read the original in Portuguese · Leer en español

Liked it? Share this story with your friendsShare on WhatsApp
Brazilian Senate chamber during a vote on the government's fiscal adjustment packageNext storyLula bets on Senate chief to save Brazil’s fiscal packageRead now →
#Brazil fiscal adjustment#Lula#Moretti Plan#Brazil economy#Chamber of Deputies#Brazil Congress

More news