Former U.S. President Joe Biden released his memoir, Promise Me, America, on November 17. In the book, Biden, who led the United States from 2021 to 2025, defends his administration and his decision to seek reelection in 2024. The book had barely reached bookstores when it drew sharp criticism. Reviewers say the most troubling part is not what Biden writes, but what he avoids.
Critics say Biden is stuck in denial
The sharpest critique came from Amy Davidson Sorkin of The New Yorker, who wrote that Biden remains “stubbornly in denial.” According to her analysis, the book offers little real news. The former president repeats that he could have won the race and only lightly touches on doubts about his own age.
Jennifer Szalai of The New York Times went in the same direction. She argued that Biden does not own his defeats. On Gaza and his decision to run for a second term, he is “embarrassed and defensive,” she wrote, on the two topics readers are most curious about. Szalai also said the author's voice is passive and that he portrays himself as a helpless victim of events.
Named and unnamed victims in Gaza
On Gaza, the difference in tone drew attention. Szalai noted that Biden uses names to identify Israeli victims but writes “no names” when he refers to Palestinian victims.
Other reviews also attacked the book's account of the relationship with Israel and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The website Jacobin, which describes itself as socialist, argues that the book portrays the relationship as far more conflictual than it actually was. Israeli commentator Amit Segal was blunter, saying that “the only consistent thing is inconsistency,” with “no doctrine or strategy” behind Biden's position.
The missing word: “equity”
David Weigel, a reporter for Semafor, pointed to another absence. Biden says he signed 17 executive orders on his first day in office, but he does not mention the order that created a racial equity approach across the federal government and required every agency to draft a DEI action plan (diversity, equity and inclusion). According to Weigel, the word “equity” does not appear in the book even once.
Discussing justice, Biden says that “every one of my legislative achievements had justice built into it,” citing “equal access to vaccines.” On gender, the silence is even greater. Biden has called discrimination against transgender people “the civil rights issue of our time,” yet the word “transgender” does not appear in the book. The first-day order banning discrimination based on gender identity is also left out.
Background and what it means beyond the United States
A memoir is not a court, but it is where many leaders shape their legacy. For readers trying to judge what worked and what did not, decisions about staying in a race, a leader's age and the conduct of the war in Gaza matter. For audiences outside the United States, the episode touches on three issues: how Washington presents its ties with Israel, how federal diversity policies are explained to the public, and how democracies hold leaders accountable for their record.
VDD editorial view: whoever governs must answer for results and choices, not only for the most comfortable version of events. The critics' question remains: will Biden take responsibility for his losses, or keep rewriting history?




