Brasília --:--:--
Politics

Moraes vote casts doubt on Brazil's Celepar privatization

Justice Alexandre de Moraes says Paraná's data safeguards are not enough, leaving the sale of the state tech company Celepar in limbo before a Nov. 30 deadline.

Justice Alexandre de Moraes at the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court during a session
Photo: Isac Nóbrega / CC BY 2.0 (Alexandre de Moraes)

Justice Alexandre de Moraes of Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF) has cast a vote that could keep the privatization of Celepar, the technology state company of Paraná, on hold for longer. Moraes followed rapporteur Flávio Dino with reservations. He said the measures taken by the state government still do not guarantee enough protection for residents' personal data. The judgment, held in the court's virtual plenary, is expected to end on Nov. 30.

Moraes says Paraná's data safeguards fall short

Celepar holds information on people who live in Paraná, a state in southern Brazil: records from the public health system (SUS), biometric data and files tied to public security. According to Moraes, data held by the state cannot be treated as “mere alienable patrimonial assets” that can simply be sold.

The justice also raised doubts about how the databases would be separated. He spoke of “administrative haste” in the hiring of B3, Brazil's stock exchange, to organize the auction.

Moraes also recalled that Brazil's General Data Protection Law (LGPD) bars private companies from processing public security data unless their capital is entirely public. He cited the constitutional amendment that made data protection a fundamental right.

Why the Celepar sale reached Brazil's Supreme Court

The sale is part of a project of Governor Ratinho Júnior, of the Social Democratic Party (PSD), who leaves office at the end of this year. The company's future will fall to his successor: Sergio Moro, of the Liberal Party (PL), takes over in 2027. The Supreme Court's decision could therefore weigh on a government that has not yet begun.

The path was already difficult. A state law signed in November 2024 authorized the sale, and the government hired B3 for R$ 1.4 million (Brazilian reais) to run the auction. Before that, the plan met resistance at the Paraná state audit court (TCE-PR), which suspended the process and demanded studies on the financial effects and on information security.

The request to block the privatization reached the STF through the Workers' Party (PT) and the Socialism and Liberty Party (PSOL), both on the left. They argue that the case invades the federal government's power to legislate on data protection and that the sale would open the way to private exploitation of public records. The Paraná government rejects that argument. It says the information would remain in the custody of public authorities and that the state would have veto power over Celepar's decisions.

In February, Dino had already allowed the process to continue in part, with conditions. Paraná must keep control over sensitive public security databases, direct oversight must be maintained, and an impact report must be delivered to the National Data Protection Authority (ANPD). Moraes agreed with that approach.

Justice Cristiano Zanin dissented. In his view, the STF should not take up the case because it challenges acts of the privatization process, not the law itself. If his position prevails in the final judgment, the sale of Celepar could be unblocked.

What the Celepar case means for investors and data rules

For foreign readers, the case shows how far Brazil's courts can shape state asset sales, even after a state legislature has approved them and the stock exchange has been hired. Investors watching Brazilian privatizations will note that sales involving public data can face extra legal hurdles, and that rules on who may hold such data remain open to interpretation.

Editorially, VDD sees a question that goes beyond Paraná: how far should the judiciary decide the fate of a state company that the state itself wants to sell, and who is accountable if data protection fails? For those who favor a smaller state and more efficient public management, each month of delay means idle money and a government project in limbo. For those worried about privacy, caution is exactly what is at stake. The answer is due by Nov. 30.

Translated and adapted from the original report by Visão da Direita (Portuguese). Read the original in Portuguese · Leer en español

Liked it? Share this story with your friendsShare on WhatsApp
Brazilian Senate chamber during a vote on the government's fiscal adjustment packageNext storyLula bets on Senate chief to save Brazil’s fiscal packageRead now →
#Celepar#Alexandre de Moraes#Paraná#Brazil Supreme Court#privatization#data protection

More news