Brasília --:--:--
Politics

28 Brazilian senators seek to move officials' trials from Supreme Court

A cross-party group of senators filed a constitutional amendment to have the STJ, not the Supreme Court, try common crimes of top Brazilian officials.

Brazilian Senate and Supreme Federal Court in Brasília
Photo: Agência Senado from Brasilia, Brazil / CC BY 2.0 (Marcos Pontes)

A group of 28 Brazilian senators from different parties filed a proposed constitutional amendment (PEC) on Wednesday (Nov. 18) that would take away from the Supreme Federal Court (STF), Brazil's highest court, the power to try common crimes committed by top officials. The task would go to the Superior Court of Justice (STJ), another of the country's high courts.

If approved, the change would affect the president and vice president, federal deputies, senators, ministers and the prosecutor general (PGR). Those who now face ordinary criminal cases before the Supreme Court would be tried by a different court.

Who signed the proposal

The list of signatories spans several parties. It includes astronaut Marcos Pontes (Liberal Party, PL, São Paulo), Senator Hamilton Mourão (Republicanos, Rio Grande do Sul), who was Brazil's vice president from 2019 to 2022, Damares Alves (Republicanos, Federal District), Cleitinho (Republicanos, Minas Gerais), Lucas Barreto (PSD, Amapá) and Eduardo Girão (Novo, Ceará).

Because the idea does not come from a single bloc, it may carry more weight when the authors start lining up support.

What the senators argue

In the text, the authors speak of improving the functioning of the Judiciary through "a better allocation of competencies" and faster proceedings. Their central argument is that the Supreme Court's constitutional role is not directly tied to trying common crimes, yet the court ends up doing so.

According to the signatories, this accumulation "could compromise the efficiency of its work in the areas of greatest relevance to the Democratic Rule of Law." Put differently, a court that should focus on constitutional questions is tied up in high-profile criminal cases.

The senators also argue that the STJ, given the nature of its duties, would be better suited to try common crimes committed by authorities of major political and institutional importance.

The obstacle: a high vote threshold

Amending Brazil's Constitution is not simple. The PEC needs 49 votes in the Senate and 308 in the Chamber of Deputies, a qualified majority that demands broad negotiation on both sides. Without that support, the proposal stalls before reaching a vote on its merits. The proposal is at the very start of its path through Congress.

Background: Brazil's privileged forum

Brazil's foro privilegiado (privileged forum) means certain officials are tried by a high court rather than by ordinary trial judges. Today, for the officials listed in the proposal, that court is the Supreme Court. The text would change which court decides the criminal cases of politicians and members of the Executive and Legislative branches, with a direct effect on how fast and how predictably those cases move. The debate also revives the question of how broad the privilege should be.

What it means beyond Brazil: balance of powers and equality before the law

For foreign readers following Brazil's institutions, the proposal shows pressure from within Congress, and from parties on the right and center, over how much criminal-case power sits in the Supreme Court. Signatories include senators from the PL, Republicanos, PSD and Novo.

From a conservative perspective, the key issue is the balance among the branches of government and equality before the law. Reducing the privileged forum and reorganizing responsibilities could relieve an overburdened court. But the change will only be legitimate if it strengthens transparency and trust in institutions and does not become one more barrier to holding officials accountable.

The next steps will show whether the PEC gains traction on the floor or falls by the wayside, like many other initiatives on the Judiciary that have tried to advance in Congress.

Translated and adapted from the original report by Visão da Direita (Portuguese). Read the original in Portuguese · Leer en español

Liked it? Share this story with your friendsShare on WhatsApp
President Lula signing the decree that ends the 6x1 work schedule in BrazilNext storyBrazil ends 6×1 work schedule: Lula decree cuts week to 42 hoursRead now →
#Brazil Supreme Court#STJ#Brazilian Senate#foro privilegiado#constitutional amendment

More news