Justice Flávio Dino of Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF), the country's highest court, decided on Tuesday, Nov. 17, to turn the dispute over the new 5x2 work schedule rules into a full merits judgment. The case will now be heard in person by the full bench in Brasília, and Brazil's Congress has only days to respond. The 5x2 schedule means five working days followed by two days off.
From injunctions to a merits ruling at Brazil's Supreme Court
Dino moved the case beyond the stage of preliminary injunctions. It covers two direct actions of unconstitutionality (ADIs), numbers 8,041 and 8,042, filed by the National Confederation of Commerce in Goods, Services and Tourism (CNC) and the National Confederation of Industry (CNI).
The shift followed a public hearing on Nov. 10. Dino pointed to doubts and disagreements over how the new rules should be applied and, in practice, concluded that the time for debating injunctions had passed. Business and union groups attended, along with the Attorney General's Office (AGU), the legal departments of the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate, and the Prosecutor General's Office (PGR).
On Nov. 12, the justice had already granted injunctions meant to increase legal certainty. They went to the court's virtual plenary and drew four votes in favor, from Dino as rapporteur, Gilmar Mendes, Cármen Lúcia and Alexandre de Moraes. The judgment stopped when Justice Luiz Fux requested a highlight (destaque), which moves the discussion to an in-person session.
Eight hours, 40 hours and the transition deadline
According to Dino, distributing the work in eight-hour days would produce a 40-hour week. He said this point still raises doubts about how the regime should be applied. The debate also covered the specifics of professional and economic categories and the different adaptation periods for administrative contracts.
The transition numbers matter most to employers and workers. Under the general rule, adjustment must happen within two months. Companies that provide services to public administration may have up to one year. Dino took into account that Dec. 16 is the date set for the start of the transition regime. Companies with government contracts therefore get breathing room, while private-sector employers have much less time.
Participants agreed on one point: the importance of collective bargaining, which is provided for in the Constitution. Still, questions remain unanswered about how to carry out the transition and what the rule will mean in practice.
Congress on hold as the Supreme Court takes the lead
The rapporteur noted that the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate opposed the injunctions and argued for rejecting the confederations' requests. Both houses now have five more days to add to their submissions, as do the groups admitted as interested parties. The AGU and the PGR get two additional days each. Only then will Dino ask for the cases to be placed on the in-person plenary calendar.
The next steps are set: final submissions from the Chamber, the Senate, the AGU and the PGR, followed by the in-person judgment. If the plenary does not rule before Dec. 16, Brazil enters the transition regime with the question still open.
Who writes Brazil's labor rules? What it means for employers and investors
For foreign readers, the dispute shows how far the Brazilian Supreme Court now shapes economic policy. Labor rules are usually the business of the legislature, but here the court is heading toward the final word.
From a conservative point of view, which is VDD's editorial line, the core issue is not only the work schedule. It is who decides the rules of work in Brazil. When Congress opposes an injunction and the Supreme Court moves ahead to the merits, the discussion stops being purely legal and becomes one about the balance between the branches of government.
Companies need predictability to plan payroll, shifts and contracts, and workers need to know what changes in their routine. With unclear rules and tight deadlines, those who produce usually end up paying the bill. That is VDD's view, not a finding of the court. For investors and companies operating in Brazil, the open question on Dec. 16 is the main risk to watch.




