Brasília --:--:--
World

Florida election tied at 3,162 votes each; coin toss picks the winner

After two recounts left Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold tied at 3,162 votes, a coin toss gave Lagner a city commission seat in Atlantic Beach.

A coin flipped in the air to settle a tied city commission election in Atlantic Beach, Florida
Illustrative photo: BrokenSphere / CC BY 3.0

In Atlantic Beach, Florida, a city commission race ended in a perfect tie, and a coin toss decided it. After two recounts, Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold each had exactly 3,162 votes. Lagner won the toss and took Seat 4 on the municipal commission.

Two recounts and no winner

Atlantic Beach is a coastal city in Duval County, in northeastern Florida. The deadlock mobilized the county's Supervisor of Elections, Jerry Holland, who ordered one manual recount and one machine recount. The result did not change: 3,162 to 3,162.

With no margin of doubt and no leftover ballots, only the tiebreaker rule remained. Under the city's rules, a tie is settled by coin tosses, and each candidate has the right to choose a side.

Heads, tails and a seat on the line

Herrold chose first and called heads. The coin landed tails, and Lagner went up 1 to 0. When it was Lagner's turn, she called heads, got it right and secured the election to Seat 4.

The winner celebrated with a line of civic pride. "This shows how great and free our country is," Lagner told a local TV station. On social media, she thanked Holland and the whole team for their work during the process and wrote: "A coin was certainly an unexpected and unforgettable way to end an election."

Herrold accepted the outcome calmly. "Jen and I have been part of this community for years... It was meant to be... We'll look back and realize how unbelievable this was," she told the local station.

"Every vote counts"

For Holland, the scene is the best civics lesson there could be. "It's remarkable, truly... what this means is that every vote matters, and a single vote can make a difference," the supervisor said.

It was not the first time Duval County settled a tie in an unconventional way. In 2014, in the race for the city council of Neptune Beach, Rory Diamond and Richard Arthur finished level, and the tiebreaker was done with numbered ping-pong balls. Arthur drew the highest number and won the seat.

Why it matters: how Brazil breaks ties, and what Florida shows about trust in elections

The case draws attention from people who follow elections in Brazil, where the logic is different. Under Brazil's Electoral Code, if a vote ends in a tie, the oldest candidate is declared elected. There is no room for a coin or a draw in majoritarian races, and the criterion is objective and predictable.

The original Visão da Direita article also makes an editorial point that applies to any serious democracy. In the United States, the tie was declared only after a manual recount and a machine recount, with the county elections supervisor overseeing the count. In the site's view, it was the transparency of the process, not the curious ending, that gave the result its legitimacy, and the losing candidate accepted the verdict without fuss. The article calls this a healthy contrast with the climate of distrust that surrounds the vote in so many contests.

Lagner now takes a seat won by the smallest of chances. It remains to be seen whether the city will review its tiebreaker rules after the episode. For now, the message is simple: in Atlantic Beach, every vote really did count.

Translated and adapted from the original report by Visão da Direita (Portuguese). Read the original in Portuguese · Leer en español

Liked it? Share this story with your friendsShare on WhatsApp
Brazilian Senate chamber during a vote on the government's fiscal adjustment packageNext storyLula bets on Senate chief to save Brazil’s fiscal packageRead now →
#Florida#coin toss#election tie#Atlantic Beach#elections#Brazil

More news