Brasília --:--:--
Government

Brazil audit court probes massage contract at Lula's ministry

Brazil's federal audit court TCU is examining a R$ 722,300 plan for about 42,000 massages for Human Rights Ministry staff, which the ministry later dropped.

Massage session, illustrating the Brazilian government contract under review by the TCU
Photo: Lula. Foto: Lula Oficial / CC BY-SA 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

Brazil's Federal Court of Accounts (TCU), the audit body that oversees federal spending, has opened a case to examine a contract for massage services for employees of the Ministry of Human Rights and Citizenship in President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's government. The contract was worth about R$ 722,300 (Brazilian reais).

What the Brazil massage contract included

The plan called for roughly 42,240 massages of 15 minutes each, spread over five years. That works out to about 8,448 sessions a year, or a little over 2,100 hours of massage annually, paid for with public money.

Based on the figures in the ministry's own bidding notice, each session would have cost about R$ 17.10. Multiplied by 42,240 sessions, that gives the R$ 722,300 total.

Who asked the TCU to investigate

The case reached the court through federal deputy Sanderson of the Liberal Party (PL), from the southern state of Rio Grande do Sul. In his formal request, he asks whether there was planning and a technical study proving the service was necessary. The case rapporteur at the TCU is Justice Jhonatan de Jesus.

Sanderson also points to a gap in the numbers. The initial estimated value was R$ 1.75 million, while the final figure was R$ 722,300. The open question is why the estimate fell so far and what justified the change.

Ministry drops the contract but defends the policy

After the bidding process became public, the ministry gave up on the contract. In a statement, it cited "budget restrictions" and said the sessions were part of its policy of well-being and quality of life at work.

In other words, the purchase was abandoned, but the argument that massage is part of a public policy was not. The TCU must now decide whether planning and technical studies justified the contract, and why the initial estimate was revised from R$ 1.75 million to R$ 722,300.

Why it matters: public spending under scrutiny

For readers outside Brazil, the TCU is the body that audits how the federal government spends public money, and its cases often shape the debate over fiscal discipline. The amount here is small against the federal budget. But the story fits a wider argument in Brazil over how the Lula government, led by the Workers' Party (PT), prioritizes spending in a country with a heavy tax burden.

The editorial view of Visão da Direita, the Brazilian conservative site behind this edition, is that the same standard should apply in every ministry: public services must be essential, planned and demonstrably necessary. In that view, lower taxes start with less waste.

For now, the ministry has not explained the drop in the estimate beyond its note. The decision is in the hands of the TCU.

Translated and adapted from the original report by Visão da Direita (Portuguese). Read the original in Portuguese · Leer en español

Liked it? Share this story with your friendsShare on WhatsApp
President Lula signing the decree that ends the 6x1 work schedule in BrazilNext storyBrazil ends 6×1 work schedule: Lula decree cuts week to 42 hoursRead now →
#Brazil#Lula#TCU#public spending#Human Rights Ministry

More news