Brasília --:--:--
Politics

Brazil Senate vote on Lula fiscal package cuts state Kandir transfers

Brazil's Senate votes four amendments to President Lula's fiscal adjustment bill, which caps Kandir Law payments to states and sets aside R$ 10.5 billion in diesel aid.

Brazilian Senate chamber in Brasília during a vote on the government's fiscal adjustment bill
Photo: Lula. Foto: Lula Oficial / CC BY-SA 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

Brazil's Senate is voting on Tuesday, November 17, on four amendments to a bill that carries the government's fiscal adjustment measures, a key test for President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in Congress. The bill's main text was already approved by 45 votes to 31. If the amendments change nothing, it moves to the Chamber of Deputies, which plans to vote on it on Wednesday, November 18.

What the Brazil fiscal adjustment bill promises

In its current version, the bill is estimated to improve Brazil's primary result (the budget balance before interest payments) by between R$ 45.1 billion and R$ 56.1 billion (Brazilian reais) in 2027. The top of that range is below the R$ 60 billion originally projected by the Finance Ministry's economic team, so the expected savings have already shrunk, even by the government's own count.

The substitute text by rapporteur Eduardo Braga, a senator from the MDB party (Amazonas state), lowers the cap on real growth in spending from 2.5% to 2% in years when the containment measures are triggered. It also widens the options for blocking budget spending.

R$ 10.5 billion in diesel subsidies left out of the target

One of the most striking points concerns the 2026 fiscal target. The report allows the government to disregard up to R$ 10.5 billion in extraordinary diesel subsidy spending when calculating whether it met the target. In practice, part of the spending stops showing up in the figure the government reports to the country.

Kandir Law: states and cities take the hit

The toughest change for governors and mayors involves transfers under the Kandir Law, the federal law that compensates states for ICMS (the state-level value-added tax) revenue lost on exports. Under the bill, those transfers would be limited to R$ 1 billion a year, compared with R$ 4 billion today, with the remainder paid in installments through 2037.

After pressure from the governor of the Federal District, Celina Leão (PP), the rapporteur removed the planned changes to transfers to the Federal District, where the capital, Brasília, is located.

The four amendments under review

  • Amendment 1, by Senator Izalci Lucas (PL-DF), would keep the current Kandir Law rules, with no annual cap and no postponement of installments.
  • Amendment 2, also by Izalci, would remove the R$ 3 billion annual limit on compensation between pension systems.
  • Amendment 3, by Senator Alan Rick (Republicanos-AC), would strike the restriction on tax credits. If approved, the government would lose the option of bringing that revenue forward to bolster its cash position.
  • Amendment 4, by Senate opposition leader Rogério Marinho (PL-RN), would restore a passage the rapporteur removed, allowing up to 40% of the accumulated balance of public funds to be used to pay other mandatory expenses.

PL stands for the Liberal Party, the main right-wing party in Brazil and the party of former president Jair Bolsonaro.

Lula's "adjustment in practice" and the political climate

Lula said: "In my government there is no sitting around discussing fiscal adjustment, I do adjustment in practice." Yet what Congress is debating is precisely the design of that adjustment.

PL leader Valdemar met the party's caucus and asked for support for Marinho in the Senate dispute. Tempers also flared in sessions on the adjustment, with an exchange of accusations between senators Randolfe and Magno Malta. Tarcísio has already said that Lula's adjustment does not tackle the structural problems of spending and debt.

Why it matters beyond Brazil: credibility of the fiscal target

For investors and others following Brazil's public finances, the key question is how credible the fiscal target is. When a target becomes easier to meet through accounting, such as excluding R$ 10.5 billion in diesel subsidies, the government's message of fiscal responsibility loses force. The bill also pushes part of the cost onto states and municipalities, which run schools, hospitals and roads, and defers payments to 2037.

In VDD's reading, a real adjustment starts by cutting spending and shrinking the size of the state, not by pushing the bill onto governors, mayors and the taxpayers of the future. While the government keeps up its "adjustment in practice" line, VDD argues, the citizen already weighed down by taxes ends up paying the bill.

If the Chamber approves the text without relevant changes, Brazil will have an adjustment that promises billions in savings but depends on limits on the state itself, flexible accounting and transfers pushed back to 2037.

Translated and adapted from the original report by Visão da Direita (Portuguese). Read the original in Portuguese · Leer en español

Liked it? Share this story with your friendsShare on WhatsApp
President Lula signing the decree that ends the 6x1 work schedule in BrazilNext storyBrazil ends 6×1 work schedule: Lula decree cuts week to 42 hoursRead now →
#Brazil fiscal adjustment#Lula#Brazilian Senate#Kandir Law#Brazil economy#Eduardo Braga

More news