The Brazilian Senate is set to vote on Wednesday, November 18, on a contested part of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's fiscal adjustment. The section directly affects the finances of states and municipalities. The bill's rapporteur, Senator Eduardo Braga of the Brazilian Democratic Movement (MDB) from Amazonas state, denied that any agreement exists with the opposition on the so-called Kandir Law. "There is no deal whatsoever," he said on arriving at the Senate. Four floor amendments (known as destaques) are scheduled for a vote in the plenary this afternoon.
What the Kandir Law is and why state money is at stake
The Kandir Law exists to compensate Brazil's states for exempting exports from tax, that is, for the revenue they forgo when a Brazilian product is sold abroad. It is a transfer from the federal government that makes a real difference to state budgets.
The text of the complementary bill cuts that compensation from R$ 4 billion to R$ 1 billion per year (Brazilian reais) between 2027 and 2030. The difference would be pushed back and paid in installments until 2037. States and municipalities say the change hits their budgets and would undermine the planning of governments that already struggle to balance their books.
The government's bargaining chip: cross-compensation of tax credits
According to the reporting, the government tried to use the Kandir cut as a bargaining chip to win the opposition's support for limiting what is known as "cross-compensation." This rule lets a company use PIS/Cofins credits (federal taxes on revenue) to offset other taxes, such as income tax, or social security debts. Limiting it tightens the screws on the businesses that produce and pay for the adjustment.
The opposition wants to keep the rule as it is and rejected the proposed deal. On Tuesday, the impasse delayed the vote on the amendments.
The government's leader in Congress, Senator Randolfe Rodrigues of the Workers' Party (PT) from Amapá state, ruled out giving up the limit on tax credits. "If we give in on tax compensation, we give up one third of the economic adjustment. I don't see that being possible on this," he said.
The numbers show the size of the bet. By the government's own reasoning, limiting the credits would bring in between R$ 12.8 billion and R$ 18.3 billion in 2027.
What this fight reveals about Lula's fiscal adjustment
With Braga denying a deal and Randolfe closing the door to concessions, a tense plenary session is expected. If the limit on credits passes, the government secures a billion-real slice of the adjustment. If the opposition blocks that section, the Planalto Palace, the seat of the presidency, will have to explain where it will find the balance in the public accounts without that revenue.
From a conservative viewpoint, the issue is not only who wins or loses this vote. The adjustment the government defends heads to the usual destination: raising revenue from those who produce and passing the bill on to states and municipalities, instead of confronting the size of public spending. When a government needs to bargain over governors' and mayors' money to close its own accounts, its weakness is already on display. Lower taxes, more predictability for those who create jobs and export, and a state that spends less are what readers should demand from Congress.
Why it matters outside Brazil
Brazil is a major exporter, and how it closes its public accounts is closely watched by investors and trading partners. This vote shows the route the Lula government prefers: more revenue from companies and a squeeze on state transfers, rather than spending cuts. How the Senate decides will indicate how much room Brasília has to impose that route, and how much the opposition can force the government to explain its numbers.




