Justice Kassio Nunes Marques of Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF), the country's highest court, intends to send former president Jair Bolsonaro's request for a criminal review to the full court. The move follows an opinion that the Prosecutor General's Office (PGR) filed with the STF on Thursday, recommending against admitting the appeal. Bolsonaro, Brazil's president from 2019 to 2022, is serving a sentence of 27 years and three months in prison for a conviction tied to the charge of attempting a coup.
Prosecutor's opinion clears the way for the review
The opinion from Prosecutor General Paulo Gonet was one of the steps still missing in the case. With it on file, Nunes Marques, who is the rapporteur (the justice in charge of the case), now has the procedural conditions to move the analysis forward. The PGR took a position against the request, but its opinion does not prevent the rapporteur from proceeding.
Nunes Marques sits on the STF's Second Panel, one of the court's two smaller chambers. Even so, he intends to submit the question to the plenary, the full court, rather than to that smaller body. The trial date will be set by the court's president, Edson Fachin.
The defense's last card and resistance inside the court
The criminal review has become the main legal strategy of Bolsonaro's defense, which is trying to annul the conviction and halt the sentence. The effort faces resistance inside the Supreme Court itself. Justices in a wing close to Alexandre de Moraes believe the chances of the request being accepted are small. They oppose both annulling the conviction and suspending the sentence through this mechanism.
Before the case goes to the plenary, Nunes Marques can also rule alone on the defense's request for an injunction to suspend the execution of the sentence. If he grants it, the other justices would later have to confirm the decision.
Who convicted Bolsonaro and who could judge now
Bolsonaro was convicted in 2025 by the STF's First Panel, with votes from Alexandre de Moraes, Cristiano Zanin, Cármen Lúcia and Flávio Dino. Luiz Fux was the dissenting vote and argued for the former president's acquittal.
In the plenary, five other justices could examine the lawyers' arguments: Kassio Nunes Marques, André Mendonça, Gilmar Mendes, Edson Fachin and Dias Toffoli. None of them was on the panel that convicted Bolsonaro. That detail gives Nunes Marques's decision its political and legal weight: the discussion leaves the body that issued the sentence and moves to a forum where the case can be examined by justices who did not vote on it.
Why it matters: a test for the Supreme Court
For Bolsonaro's supporters, the criminal review is a chance for the STF to re-examine a conviction they consider unjust, and for a former president to be heard by justices who did not take part in the first trial. In VDD's view, the mechanism exists precisely to review convictions, which shows that the debate is legitimate and should not be treated as an affront.
The outcome is far from certain. The PGR is opposed, and the wing tied to Moraes is already signaling skepticism. The question the plenary will have to face is whether the STF is willing to review a conviction handed down by its own court, and not just by one of its panels.
For readers outside Brazil, the case is a gauge of how the country's highest court handles one of the most sensitive political cases in the country, and of how it treats a legal remedy that exists to revisit convictions.
What comes next
The next steps depend on Nunes Marques and Fachin. The rapporteur may decide on the injunction seeking to suspend the sentence, and the court's president will set when the plenary analyzes the merits. Until then, the request remains the main bet of Bolsonaro's defense.




