Brasília --:--:--
BreakingBolsonaro moved to ICU in Brasília; medical bulletin says he is stable2 h ago
Justice

Moraes backs charges against Brazil lawmaker Van Hattem

Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes voted to accept slander and insult charges against Marcel Van Hattem, amid a clash between the court and Congress.

Justice Alexandre de Moraes at the Brazilian Supreme Court and lawmaker Marcel Van Hattem
Photo: Isac Nóbrega / CC BY 2.0 (Alexandre de Moraes)

Justice Alexandre de Moraes of Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF), the country's highest court, has announced an early vote in favor of accepting criminal charges against federal lawmaker Marcel Van Hattem, of the Novo party, from the southern state of Rio Grande do Sul. Van Hattem is accused of slander (calúnia) and insult (injúria) against Federal Police (PF) investigator Fábio Shor. Moraes sided with the case's rapporteur, Justice Flávio Dino.

A detail that weighs on the case

The detail that stands out is the investigator's post. According to the source, Shor has worked in Moraes's office since March. In other words, the police officer who says he was offended by an opposition lawmaker sits alongside the justice who is now voting to move the accusation forward.

Parliamentary immunity under pressure

Van Hattem is entitled to parliamentary immunity, especially when he speaks from the floor of the Chamber of Deputies. The Constitution provides for it so that lawmakers can criticize authorities without fear of prosecution. Those around the lawmaker say the guarantee is being ignored in practice.

The deputy has not backed down. In recent days he sharply criticized the STF and promised to go to the “last consequences” against what he calls judicial activism. At another point he appealed to Justice André Mendonça: “Your Excellency is in a position to put Moraes in his proper place.”

Why it matters: Brazil's court and Congress at odds

While the case moves forward, a criminal complaint (notícia-crime) has been filed against Moraes himself. The climate between the Supreme Court and part of Congress is already at boiling point, and each decision is now read as a political message.

What happens next depends on how the trial proceeds and how the other justices vote. If the charges are accepted, the deputy will formally face prosecution over criticism made in the exercise of his mandate, and the precedent is expected to be debated in Congress for a long time.

What the Van Hattem case means for free speech and checks and balances

For foreign readers, the central question is simple: when a legislator can be prosecuted for what he says on the floor or from the rostrum, the voice of the voters who elected him is weakened too. Brazil's right sees the episode as another sign that the STF is encroaching on the prerogatives of the legislative branch. That, in the view of VDD, should concern anyone who defends freedom of expression and the separation of powers.

The case also shows how tense relations between branches of government in Brazil have become, with a justice voting in a case where the alleged victim works in his own office, and a complaint pending against that same justice.

Translated and adapted from the original report by Visão da Direita (Portuguese). Read the original in Portuguese · Leer en español

Liked it? Share this story with your friendsShare on WhatsApp
Former Brazilian president Jair BolsonaroNext storyBolsonaro rushed to hospital in Brasília with severe abdominal painRead now →
#Van Hattem#Alexandre de Moraes#Brazil Supreme Court#Parliamentary immunity#Free speech#Novo party

More news