São Paulo Governor Tarcísio de Freitas, of the Republicanos party, launched a sharp attack on the fiscal adjustment package of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's government. Speaking on Monday (Nov. 16) at Agro Fórum 2026, an event promoted by the Brazilian investment bank BTG Pactual, he said Lula "bought reelection on a credit card" and that the country is now preparing to receive the bill.
"In a way, the president bought the election on a credit card and now the bill is coming," the governor said. In his view, the package does not tackle the underlying problems: spending and debt.
Package aims at the target, not the root of the problem
The Brazilian Senate approved the package's base text on Thursday (Nov. 12). It includes cuts to tax benefits, spending-containment mechanisms and restrictions on tax offsets. Four amendments (known in Brazil as "destaques") are still to be voted on Tuesday (Nov. 17) before the proposal moves to the Chamber of Deputies.
Tarcísio acknowledged that the package is a first step. But he argued that the government is focused only on meeting its 2027 fiscal target. According to him, the announced savings are overstated, and part of the measures merely brings forward tax revenue. In other words, the money comes in sooner, but the problem stays where it was.
States and municipalities may get the bill
The governor pointed to two items that directly affect regional budgets. The first is the postponement of transfers under the Kandir Law, which compensate states for losses from the tax exemption on exports. The second is the limits on social security offsets. In his assessment, the changes put pressure on the finances of state governments and city halls and carry a risk of litigation.
The practical meaning: those who run health, security and schools day to day may be left with the squeeze, while Brasília celebrates a balanced number on paper.
Room for new spending
Tarcísio also raised a political warning. He said the package opens space for other expenses, since part of the savings could finance new spending. He said there is uncertainty about which of Lula's campaign promises will make it into the 2027 budget, and about whether the measures can contain the growth of spending and debt.
The governor acknowledged only one structural advance: the review of tax benefits. Even so, he noted that the package lacked an analysis separating obsolete incentives from those needed for business competitiveness. Without that filter, the cut could hit those who produce and employ. Tarcísio also defended fiscal measures that would make room for lower interest rates.
Why high spending and debt hit Brazilians' wallets
Rising public spending and growing debt tend to go hand in hand with high interest rates. That means more expensive credit for shopkeepers, farmers and families financing a home. When an adjustment relies on more revenue instead of spending cuts, the taxpayer pays, and the pressure on states and cities can return as tighter public services or higher taxes.
The Senate vote shows that approval was not smooth. Before the base text, the package's urgency request passed by a narrow 40 votes to 38. Lula, for his part, defends the adjustment and says the poor will not pay the bill.
What the debate means for investors watching Brazil
Tarcísio chose a stage organized by one of Brazil's best-known investment banks to deliver his message, and the content speaks directly to the market: whether the fiscal effort rests on spending restraint or on extra revenue, and how that affects interest rates. In the editorial view of VDD, a government that wants to lower the cost of credit needs to show that spending and debt are under control, not only that a fiscal target is met on paper. Investors and trading partners following Brazil will be looking at how the 2027 budget treats the president's electoral promises.
What comes next
After the amendments are voted on Tuesday, the package goes to the Chamber of Deputies, where it is expected to face a new debate over the weight of the measures on states and municipalities. For those who favor a leaner government, the path runs through spending cuts rather than seeking more revenue. The question Tarcísio left hanging is who will pay the bill when it arrives.




